MAIN REPORT
An 89-page decision and the boundaries of appeal
Three justices of California’s Second District Court of Appeal affirmed the lower court’s judgment. Reports from AP and Bloomberg Law say the panel found no reversible trial error among the issues Masterson raised. An appeal is not a repeat of the original jury trial. Its central task is to assess whether legal or evidentiary mistakes undermined the verdict.
The defense disputed the handling of the statute of limitations, the exclusion of material it regarded as favorable and the trial judge’s treatment of religious evidence. The appeals panel rejected those challenges as well as Masterson’s petition claiming inadequate assistance from previous counsel. Its decision preserves the two convictions reached in 2023 rather than deciding new charges.
Why testimony about Scientology mattered
Particularly contentious was the account of why the women did not immediately approach police. The accusers, who were formerly associated with the Church of Scientology, testified about interactions that, they said, discouraged reporting.
















