MAIN CONTENT
A lottery for the magnet schools
Montgomery County’s magnet schools offer enriched programmes in maths, science or the humanities for high-achieving students in grades six to eight, including Takoma Park Middle School in Silver Spring and Martin Luther King Jr. Middle School in Germantown. The new selection process was introduced in the 2021-2022 school year, during the COVID-19 pandemic.
- All students are screened for academic potential to create an eligible pool.
- Each student’s test scores are compared with those of peers whose family incomes are at a similar level, grouped by low-, moderate- and high-poverty schools.
- A lottery then randomly assigns students to a magnet school or to enriched instruction at a local school.
The parents who sued argue that Asian American students are clustered in high-performing, low-poverty elementary schools, so comparing them within income bands makes it harder for them to enter the lottery pool, reducing their numbers at the magnet schools.
Two understandings of equality
The parent coalition, the Association for Education Fairness, is represented by the Pacific Legal Foundation, a libertarian legal group that has pursued similar challenges in Virginia and Massachusetts. It argues the policy, while race-neutral on its face, uses proxies such as economic background to achieve a race-based result.

















