A wound that has not closed
Speaking to CNN Portugal, Castello Branco argued that Israel has never moved past the moment of the attack. Instead of a period of mourning and reflection, the country plunged into a prolonged war on several fronts, leaving little space to process collective loss.
“Israel is still living through October 7th. At best, it's October 8th.” — José Tomaz Castello Branco, commentator on CNN Portugal
Grief, psychologists often note, requires a sense of safety and an end to immediate danger. For many Israelis, that has not come: sirens, rocket fire, reservist call-ups and news of new attacks have punctuated the past three years. Even the recent attempted hijacking of a flydubai flight bound for Tel Aviv revived fears that the threat has not passed.
Three years of war and waiting
The events that followed October 7 have kept the country in a state of emergency. The main milestones include:
- The Hamas-led attack killed about 1,200 people in Israel, mostly civilians, and around 250 people were taken hostage into Gaza.
- Israel's military campaign in Gaza killed tens of thousands of Palestinians and devastated the territory; a ceasefire took effect nearly a year ago, though deadly strikes continue.

















