A script that keeps repeating
Videos released by police tend to follow the same script: a man shot in the lower leg hobbles through the darkness as officers lead him away. According to police posts, suspects flee, fire on officers, and police shoot to disable rather than kill. The tactic, known as “Operation Langda” or “Operation Lame,” is used against suspected cow smugglers as well as for crimes such as theft and rape.
This is a dangerous situation. It’s become a routine police practice. Instead of investigating, police kill or injure a person and justice is done.
Some activists argue police have shifted from “encounter killings” to shooting to injure, so-called “half encounters,” to spark less public outcry. They also say the practice is spreading to neighboring BJP-run states such as Haryana, Bihar, Uttarakhand and the outskirts of Delhi.
The authorities push back
Amitabh Yash, a senior Uttar Pradesh official, told the AP that police are instructed to respond only in self-defense, that there is no order to shoot suspects in the leg, and that police in the state have killed and injured fewer suspects per capita than police in the US. He said he would investigate the pattern of injuries if an appropriate complaint were lodged.
The police must be questioned for every action they take. Every action is open to scrutiny, whether it’s a death or an injury.
Yash rejected claims that justice had been politicized, said there is no career incentive tied to shootings, and argued that the high share of Muslims among suspects reflects the large number of Muslims in the cattle trade.
State police say the zero tolerance policy has increased fear among criminals and strengthened public security.
Figures and evidence
The Center for the Study of Organized Hate, a Washington think tank, compiled the records and shared them exclusively with the AP, which independently reviewed about 200 cases. The data cover only incidents publicized by police themselves and are almost certainly an undercount:
- About 650 suspected cow smugglers have been shot and injured by police since 2020, nearly 93% of identifiable cases involving Muslims
- From March 2017 to October 13, 2026, at least 316 suspects were killed in encounters, 110 of them Muslim, while Muslims make up about one-fifth of the state’s population
- Over the same period, 12,890 suspects were injured, while 18 police officers were killed and 1,953 injured in the line of duty
It’s not a shot in defence. It’s a deliberate close shot of a person.
Forensic medicine professor Mohd Kaleem Khan of Aligarh Muslim University said it was highly unlikely a bullet could pass horizontally through the calf of a fleeing or struggling person without hitting bone, especially from a distance.
Courts speak out as families live in fear
In January, the Allahabad High Court, the state’s highest judicial authority, issued a rare public rebuke of the rising number of police shootings, warning that officers cannot replace the justice system. Another judge voiced “deep constitutional concern” over a “culture of institutional impunity.” Yet a 2018 petition seeking independent investigation of encounters remains pending.
This court has noticed that the practice of police encounters, particularly firing at the legs of accused persons, has seemingly become a routine feature.
The AP spoke with families of six Muslim men shot in the leg; all asked not to be named out of fear. One mother said her son, who traded buffalo to support the family, is now disabled and cannot work, leaving them dependent on charity. Another said her son was shot in both knees and the family survives on small loans.
















