MAIN ARTICLE
A scan finding is not a surgical verdict
The knee contains several possible sources of pain, including menisci, cartilage, ligaments, tendons and surrounding tissues. In middle-aged and older adults, an MRI-detected meniscal tear can be part of an aging joint rather than the sole cause of symptoms. Clinicians therefore need to assess the history, walking pattern, strength, range of motion and symptom severity alongside imaging. A radiology report identifies anatomy; it does not independently identify the best treatment.
Crucially, a degenerative meniscal tear is not equivalent to a traumatic tear following a sudden sports injury. The former often responds to conservative care, while the latter may involve displaced tissue, instability or genuine mechanical locking that warrants prompt specialist evaluation. Simplistic claims in either direction—every tear needs surgery or no tear ever does—ignore these differences. A good treatment plan starts with the right diagnosis and the patient's actual functional limitations.
Five-year evidence supports exercise therapy
The Dutch ESCAPE randomized trial enrolled 321 adults aged 45 to 70 with degenerative meniscal tears. Participants received either arthroscopic partial meniscectomy or a structured, exercise-based physical therapy program.

















