Beijing's response
At a regular press briefing on October 26, Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun said educational exchanges between China and the United States are mutually beneficial and help deepen mutual understanding. A day earlier, Xinhua called the national security threat label an absurd overreach, reflecting some US politicians' warped threat perceptions and a political calculation to stir up anti-China sentiment before the midterm elections.
The Pentagon's allegations
The US side has made serious allegations against Confucius Institutes. Key points:
- On October 23, the US Defense Department added Confucius Institutes to its list of organisations threatening national security.
- Secretary Pete Hegseth alleged that the institutes were operating in disguise at US universities.
- According to him, some 80 new units had appeared at 30 universities under different names and charters.
- He said the Defense Department had dismantled every one of these organisations over the past two months.
To steal intellectual property and to infiltrate the minds of American students.
Two opposing views
Washington has long accused Confucius Institutes of being Chinese propaganda tools and has repeatedly acted to curb them. Supporters of a tough approach argue universities must be protected from foreign influence and the risk of technology leakage.
Beijing, by contrast, insists these are ordinary language and cultural centres, similar to those many other countries operate abroad. Some educators also worry that excessive restrictions could reduce American students' opportunities to learn Chinese and understand China.
Education in a geopolitical whirlwind
The Pentagon's decision came just over a week before the US midterm elections, as US-China relations remain tense on many fronts, from trade and technology to security. When education is viewed through a security lens, academic exchange, long a bridge between the two peoples, risks shrinking. The question is how to protect security without closing the door to understanding.
Learning without thought is labour lost; thought without learning is perilous.















