MAIN CONTENT
The court avoids replacing the Shin Bet’s professional judgment
During the hearing, Shin Bet and state representatives presented judges with a professional assessment of the threats against Golan and the measures proposed in response. After hearing part of the material behind closed doors, Supreme Court President Isaac Amit indicated that the court should not replace the security service in decisions involving personal protection.
That did not amount to dismissing the threats. Amit said the Shin Bet was instructing, and would continue to instruct, the police on Golan’s security and that the protection provided should correspond to the threat level, which is under continuous review. The suggestion that Golan withdraw the petition therefore reflects the court’s view that the matter should primarily be resolved through professional security channels rather than a direct judicial order.
Dozens of threats raise questions about equal protection
The Democrats’ petition documented dozens of threats posted from July through late September, including calls for Golan to be shot or hanged and threats directed at members of his family. Police reportedly assessed the threat against him at level 4 on a six-level scale.














