A 55-page ruling
Judge Jesse M. Furman of the Southern District of New York, an appointee of President Barack Obama, rejected the Justice Department's argument that Comey, as a federal prosecutor, was an executive branch employee whom the president has broad authority to fire.
“…flies in the face of nearly two centuries of Supreme Court precedent.” — Judge Jesse M. Furman
In his 55-page opinion, he wrote that accepting the government's argument would unsettle the very equilibrium established by the US constitutional system. The judge ordered the Justice Department to retroactively reinstate Comey and pay her back wages from her firing in July 2025 until she joined a private law firm in December of that year. A Justice Department spokesperson said the department disagrees and will appeal.
A highly rated prosecutor
According to the ruling, Comey was assigned some of the department's most prominent cases and consistently received high praise from supervisors and peers. Yet she was fired on July 16, 2025, shortly after the trial of music mogul Sean Combs in Manhattan concluded, without being given a reason.

















