A case closed after a summary
The woman reported the alleged assault to campus police about three weeks after the October 2024 night at the Chi Phi house, giving investigators a detailed account over two days. She also spoke with Cornell's disciplinary investigators. But Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten declined to pursue charges or further inquiry after reviewing only a police summary of her interview.
When her civil lawsuit was filed last month, Van Houten said it contained allegations he had never seen. He accused Cornell police of omitting key material, including a transcript in which she said she was "100% confident" she had been raped. The documents he received, he said, suggested she had consented to some sexual acts, had not been forced into others and was intoxicated but not helpless. He has since reopened the investigation.
Seeking justice sometimes requires us to reconsider or reopen cases when we are provided with additional evidence.
Governor Hochul was unconvinced. She said the prosecutor had failed to do the "bare minimum," arguing that he should have requested more information from Cornell and interviewed the woman before closing the file.















