MAIN CONTENT
An idea considered, then shelved
Responding to a written question from Reform Jersey deputy Tom Coles, Maclean said it was a “joint decision” by the two ministers after reviewing officers’ advice, analysing housing market conditions and weighing the potential cost to the public purse.
- Original aim: encourage older people in large homes to “right-size” into smaller ones.
- Expectation: free up more homes for families who need space.
- Conclusion: insufficient evidence that a stamp duty holiday would deliver the desired effect.
Maclean said the government would continue to consider “non-tax measures that may support right-sizing and improve housing market mobility”.
What is the real barrier?
The crux of the government’s reasoning is identifying the right cause. The analysis found tax costs are not the main reason older people hesitate to leave their large homes.

















