MAIN ARTICLE
A judge insists that evidence, not publicity, decide the dispute
On November 18, US District Judge Lewis Kaplan in Manhattan rejected JPMorgan’s request to throw out former banker Chirayu Rana’s lawsuit. The bank had accused Rana of encouraging his sister Chandani Rana and friend Allan Flott to give untruthful accounts of alleged misconduct by executive Lorna Hajdini. A particularly contested episode concerns an alleged remark implying control over Rana: his sister subsequently recanted her earlier testimony.
Kaplan said he could not determine whether the original account or the recantation was truthful on the available record. Deciding witness credibility ordinarily calls for the orderly testing of evidence and, potentially, evaluation by a jury. A refusal to dismiss the action therefore should not be mistaken for a finding that harassment happened, or that either witness committed perjury.
The judge expressed frustration that litigation had partly taken the form of a public-relations battle. He urged participants to pursue their claims and defenses through the court. That distinction matters when highly personal allegations circulate widely before testimony has been tested through cross-examination and ordinary procedural safeguards.

















