A controversial ruling
According to The Times of Israel, Lior’s ruling argues that the Jewish people never gave up on the Land of Israel and that Arabs never bought the land from Jews, so he regards land in their hands as having been seized. On that basis, he says Jews may pick olives in areas far from Jewish communities to publicly demonstrate ownership, describing this as fulfilling the commandment to conquer the land.
The ruling was a response to a letter last week from a small group of rabbis in Gush Etzion, which said that eating Palestinians’ olives was not only theft but also a desecration of God’s name.
Opposition from moderate rabbis
Tzohar, a group of moderate religious Zionist rabbis, criticized Lior’s ruling and stressed that individuals cannot decide on their own to confiscate other people’s property for security reasons.
Theft is forbidden from anyone, Jew or non-Jew alike.
The group also praised the Gush Etzion rabbis who had spoken out earlier. Opposition from within the religious community shows that Lior’s interpretation does not represent all Jewish rabbis, and that universal ethical principles remain a foundation for many.














