MAIN CONTENT
How two purported orders triggered 129 website blocks
Reuters’ November 11 investigation traced two Department of Telecommunications blocking directives, dated July 21 and September 2, to documents purporting to come from the Rajasthan High Court and Allahabad High Court. People claiming to be legal representatives had emailed those purported rulings to government officials. The first directive covered 34 betting websites, while the second concerned 95, bringing the total to 129. By the time internet service providers received an official instruction, an unverified claim of judicial authority had been converted into operational state action.
Reuters found no matching orders in the courts’ registration systems. A Rajasthan High Court registrar said the document bearing that court’s identity appeared fraudulent, while the Allahabad High Court confirmed that the other order was not genuine and filed a police complaint on November 6. These findings raise an institutional question distinct from the legality of gambling: why was a direct, independent check with the relevant court apparently absent before access was restricted?
A summons at the top of the bureaucracy
Two officials familiar with the matter told Reuters on November 14 that the prime minister’s office had instructed Telecom Secretary Amit Agrawal to appear in person, interrupting a trip to another Indian state. Agrawal is the most senior civil servant in the ministry overseeing telecommunications operators and internet providers.
One official said field officers had executed the measures against betting accounts, but that explanation does not settle who was responsible for verifying the authenticity of the documents on which those measures depended.
The ministry has initiated an internal investigation, and state police have requested records in a criminal inquiry into possible forgery and cheating by unidentified individuals. As of Reuters’ November 14 report, Agrawal, the ministry and Modi’s office had not responded to requests for comment. It would therefore be premature to attribute the failure to negligence, a defective workflow or deliberate collusion. A credible investigation must examine the records and separate those possibilities rather than assume an answer.
Why official-looking seals and QR codes prove so little
The forged orders reportedly displayed court symbols and seals, along with a QR code that could give readers a false impression of authenticity. Reuters found that the QR code accompanying the purported Allahabad High Court document led to an unrelated page, not an authoritative verification record. A plausible signature block, an impressive seal or a case number is not proof that a judge issued an order. Genuine verification must take place through trusted court records and independent institutional channels, rather than contact details supplied by the sender.
The vulnerability became more striking because the purported orders and related correspondence appeared on the Department of Telecommunications website for months. Reuters reported that one false order had been removed by November 14, while the other remained accessible when checked that day. Documents passing through several administrative stages without effective challenge underscore the value of traceable decisions, documented authenticity checks and a mechanism for suspending enforcement when inconsistencies emerge.
A dispute about betting becomes a question of digital rights
India has a legitimate interest in enforcing restrictions on unlawful online gambling. Yet a lawful public objective cannot make a forged judicial basis legitimate. If someone can impersonate a court to activate blocking powers, other targets could eventually include legitimate businesses, civil society groups or lawful speech. The issue is therefore not simply whether governments should remove prohibited material; it is how their authority is authenticated, reviewed and contested before a digital service disappears from public view.
Another episode reported by Reuters this month sharpened those concerns. X told a Delhi court that takedown notices purporting to come from police and targeting accounts belonging to two internet-freedom organizations were fake. No connection between the two incidents has been established. Together, however, they illustrate the danger of enforcement systems that emphasize rapid compliance without equally robust verification of the requesting authority. Public confidence will depend not only on punishment for forgery, but on transparent reforms and meaningful ways to challenge mistaken blocks.
















