ARTICLE
What the jury decided about public promises
Privacy controls and community rules offer a visible sense of order, while the systems behind them remain largely out of sight. New Mexico argued that Facebook’s public explanations diverged enough from its practices to violate consumer protection law. Following a two-week trial in Santa Fe, jurors found 26 of the 29 specified statements misleading. The result concerns particular representations, rather than every assertion the company has ever made.
Those representations addressed the collection, protection, sharing and use of personal information, alongside policies concerning hate speech and misinformation. The jury did not endorse the state’s entire case. Reuters reported that it rejected claims tied to certain statements about efforts to remove harmful material and fact-checking. That distinction matters because a verdict on selected claims cannot fairly be presented as a finding that every moderation or privacy promise was false.
The New Mexico Department of Justice put the statutory count at 43,899,725 violations. It reflects the application of consumer law to the challenged statements and affected audience. It is neither a count of confirmed account breaches nor an amount already owed in damages. A violation, an individual consumer and an exposed data record describe different things; mixing them obscures both the reach and the limits of the finding.














