MAIN ARTICLE
Two individual experiences, an industry-wide test
S.J., a 16-year-old from Illinois, and K.D.B., an 18-year-old from Mississippi, filed their lawsuits in 2023. According to accounts of their court filings, they began watching YouTube at three or four years old and adopted other platforms around age nine. They argue that infinite scrolling, autoplay and incentives to return repeatedly contributed to compulsive use, disrupted sleep and concentration, and mental health conditions including anxiety, depression and eating disorders. These remain allegations to be tested by evidence, not established medical or legal findings about the defendants.
TikTok and YouTube settled with both plaintiffs before trial. S.J. also resolved her claims against Meta, leaving Snap facing claims from both young women and Meta facing K.D.B.'s case. The proceeding is expected to last weeks, with Meta chief Mark Zuckerberg, Instagram chief Adam Mosseri and Snap chief Evan Spiegel expected to testify. Jurors will have to assess what each plaintiff experienced, what each company designed and whether any proven misconduct actually caused the claimed injuries.
When engagement becomes a disputed design choice
The lawsuits do not simply target a particular offensive post. The plaintiffs' lawyers focus on the architecture of digital attention: recommendation systems, endless feeds, autoplay and features rewarding a continuing sequence of interactions. Such tools can also support communication, discovery and creativity. The disputed question is whether companies adequately considered foreseeable risks when introducing these mechanisms to children and adolescents. Evidence may include product records, internal communications and expert testimony about how features affect user behavior.
















