MAIN ARTICLE
An argument for changing the intelligence boundary
David S. Cohen, who served as CIA deputy director during the Obama and Biden administrations, argues that private companies increasingly develop capabilities critical to American security. In his view, refusing to collect intelligence for commercial advantage can put US firms at a disadvantage when rival governments do not follow comparable limits.
Cohen suggests lifting the restriction while directing any such program toward strategic adversaries, including China, Russia, Iran and North Korea. The argument is a proposal from a former official, rather than an announcement that Washington has adopted new intelligence operations.
What the 2014 directive actually says
Presidential Policy Directive 28, signed on January 17, 2014, permits collection of foreign confidential business information where necessary for the national security of the United States or its partners. It expressly rules out collecting such information solely to provide an American company or industry with a commercial advantage.
That distinction matters: investigating a vulnerable defense supply chain differs from obtaining a foreign chipmaker’s proprietary design and handing it to a domestic competitor. Changing the rule would raise difficult questions about beneficiaries, oversight, confidentiality and public accountability.

















