A Letter on the Third Anniversary
The letter was published on Oct. 7, 2026, exactly three years after the Hamas attack that sparked the war in Gaza. The signatories, retired senior officers and legal experts, argue that the genocide allegations do not meet the established definition and standards of the crime, are unsupported by the facts and do not withstand common-sense scrutiny.
According to JINSA, the signatories call on those making the allegations to apply the Genocide Convention faithfully and to distinguish clearly between the tragic consequences of combat, potential violations of the law of armed conflict and the specific legal crime of genocide. The letter also acknowledges the immense suffering endured by Palestinian civilians in Gaza.
The Argument Over Intent and Civilian Protection
At the heart of the letter is the question of intent. The signatories say genocide is not a quantitative crime and that no number of civilian casualties in itself constitutes genocide. They cite a series of measures taken by the Israeli military:
- Advance warnings, evacuation instructions and protected humanitarian corridors.
- Tactical pauses to allow civilians to move and aid to enter.














