A third knock on the Supreme Court’s door
Judge Chen’s ruling, which found that former Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem violated a federal law governing the actions of agencies, was upheld by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The Supreme Court paused that ruling at the administration’s request in October 2025, but the pause expired this month. Earlier still, the Supreme Court had lifted a temporary order Chen issued at an early stage of the case.
Now the 9th Circuit’s ruling is set to take effect on Friday, forcing the Justice Department back to the nation’s top court once more. In its filing, the department warned of the consequences of a delay:
Absent judicial intervention between now and November 20, the Department of Homeland Security will have to resurrect TPS status for hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans after a 19-month hiatus.
The human cost
Behind the legal arguments lie the lives of hundreds of thousands of families. The two sides paint sharply contrasting pictures:
- According to the Justice Department, reviving TPS would scuttle the deportation of hundreds of people with final orders of removal.
- The government would also have to immediately release around 1,800 Venezuelans who are currently detained.
- According to the plaintiffs, since the Supreme Court’s previous intervention, TPS holders have been detained, separated from children who are American citizens, deported to Venezuela or sent to “third countries” where they have no ties.
TPS lets migrants from countries stricken by war, natural disaster or other catastrophes live and work legally in the United States while it is unsafe to return home.
The Trump administration argues that the protections were always meant to be temporary.
The Haiti and Syria precedent
On June 25, the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that the administration could end TPS for hundreds of thousands of Haitians and Syrians. Writing for the majority, Justice Samuel Alito concluded that the TPS statute bars courts from reviewing termination decisions, while Justice Elena Kagan, in dissent, stressed that previous homeland security secretaries had repeatedly found conditions in both countries too dangerous for return. The Supreme Court then ordered the 9th Circuit to apply that ruling to the Venezuelan case.
The Justice Department argues that the 9th Circuit ignored that instruction and voiced frustration at having to repeat the same fight:
The 9th Circuit has forced the government to return to this court for a third time and rehash nearly identical arguments without even a hint of justification.
Is Venezuela safe to return to?
The U.S. State Department still warns Americans to reconsider travel to Venezuela due to the risk of crime, kidnapping and poor health infrastructure. After the U.S. operation targeting President Nicolás Maduro in January, Noem said Venezuela was “more free” than before and pledged to continue ending the protections.
Immigrant advocates counter that political change does not mean safety for returnees, as the economy remains devastated and violence has not subsided. Some former Homeland Security officials note that when a country falls into turmoil, U.S. administrations typically consider expanding, not shrinking, temporary protections.
















