A promise and a warning
Speaking on the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, Burnham promised to "grasp the nettle" of social care with a national care service free at the point of use, criticising predecessors for their timidity. Baroness Casey's independent commission will report next summer on how it should be built. Within hours, however, Downing Street clarified that the service would not mirror the NHS and would exclude the costs of bed and board in care homes.
It's a figment of a very rich imagination to imagine that free personal care will solve all the problems that Andy Burnham has listed.
Macaskill, head of Scottish Care, which represents independent care providers, says the vision behind Scotland's policy was right, but its implementation has worked less and less well year after year.
Scotland's hard lessons
According to Macaskill, the list of services covered by free personal care was steadily narrowed, and eligibility criteria are now so tight that most Scottish councils operate at the critical level, offering packages only to those with the greatest needs.

















