An investigation that ended almost as soon as it began
Speaking to AP on Wednesday, October 7, attorney Thomas Giuffra said that as the woman, identified as Jane Doe in court documents, took her allegations through Cornell's internal disciplinary process, the university police gave her the impression that a criminal investigation was ongoing. In reality, District Attorney Matthew Van Houten had decided not to bring charges within days of her giving detailed accounts to police.
Van Houten has said he asked Cornell police to convey the decision to the accuser, but he never spoke to her or her lawyer personally. Giuffra said that even he, involved in the case from early on, assumed investigators simply needed more time to interview witnesses, and had no idea that nothing was being done. He said:
I think she was misled.
Two conflicting accounts
Last week, Van Houten said that after reviewing a six-page summary of the woman's account written by a police officer, his office believed no crime had been committed and that her participation in drug use and sex was voluntary. That description sharply contradicts what she told police and university investigators, and what she alleged in a lawsuit filed last month against seven Chi Phi members, Cornell and others. According to Giuffra, the summary left out crucial points:

















