A 2-1 ruling that crossed party lines

After an unusual emergency hearing held online on Sunday, Judges Mark Bennett – a Trump appointee – and Gabriel Sanchez – a Biden appointee – concluded that the appeals court lacked authority to rule before the district court had addressed the matter. Judge Patrick Bumatay, also a Trump appointee, dissented. The case returns to the US District Court in California, where a hearing was scheduled for Tuesday.

“The United States's claimed emergency, at least in part, is a self-constructed one.” — Majority opinion of the 9th Circuit

According to the majority, part of the delay stemmed from the government's late filing, its slowness in realizing that California state law governs the issuance and processing of ballots, and its failure to account for the fact that the state has millions of voters and processes ballots on a schedule matching that scale.

Judge Bennett: running elections belongs to the states

In a separate concurrence, Bennett wrote that had the court been able to decide the case now, he would have ruled against the Justice Department on the merits. In his view, the federal law cited does not preempt the states' primary authority in election administration; California can still – and in fact must – craft its own procedures for congressional elections.