MAIN ARTICLE
A courtroom ending without a final verdict
Attorneys for MaryAnne Lindsey, Surenthia Jenkins, Miranda Lofton and Sandra Simpson announced agreements with L’Oréal’s US subsidiary and other defendants. The women filed their cases in Cook County, Illinois, in 2023 and 2024. Jury selection started on November 9, but the parties reached terms before jurors delivered any decision on liability.
The amounts and other terms remain confidential. Plaintiffs’ attorney Danielle Ward Mason expressed hope that the resolution would offer the women a measure of justice. Legally, however, a negotiated settlement resolves the named disputes; it is neither a scientific determination about a product nor a binding verdict covering everyone with a pending claim.
What the science establishes—and what it cannot
The scientific flashpoint was a National Institutes of Health paper released in October 2022. Researchers analyzed 33,497 American women enrolled in the Sister Study and followed them for nearly 11 years, identifying 378 uterine cancer cases. Women reporting more than four uses of hair-straightening products in the preceding year were more than twice as likely to develop uterine cancer as women who reported no use.















