Two hours of argument, no clear answer
The first case of the new term is one of the most significant on global warming the Supreme Court has ever handled. The justices put sharp questions to both sides, but after the argument it remained unclear which way they would rule.
The stakes are immense. If allowed to proceed in Colorado state court, the lawsuit could open the door to thousands of similar claims by municipalities nationwide over the effects of climate change on health and infrastructure, potentially leading to huge settlements and damages that the oil industry warns could bankrupt it. Governments in places such as San Francisco, Massachusetts and Hawaii are pursuing similar cases.
The tobacco and opioid comparison
Boulder and other localities hope climate lawsuits will become the environmental equivalent of the landmark litigation that produced major judgments against tobacco companies and opioid makers. Justice Elena Kagan, a liberal, suggested there was little distinction between Boulder’s case and those earlier suits.
This is the same kind of lawsuit against the same kind of actors.















