MAIN CONTENT
The unfinished fifth of a diplomatic bargain
At a November 15 briefing, Philippine Foreign Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro said negotiators had reached provisional agreement on approximately four-fifths of a proposed South China Sea Code of Conduct, or COC. Accounts from CNA and the Philippine News Agency indicate that this represents substantial progress from the roughly half-completed text earlier in the Philippine chairmanship. But the disputed remainder contains questions that determine what kind of instrument the region would actually receive.
One unresolved issue is whether the eventual code will be legally binding. Others concern its geographical reach and the conduct expected of vessels in contested waters. A diplomatic statement expressing goodwill is not equivalent to enforceable rules on dangerous maneuvers, incident communications and restraint. The percentage of text provisionally settled therefore says little about how much operational risk has disappeared.
The parties have reportedly resolved one important connection: the proposed code would build on the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea, known as the DOC. Manila has also described voluntary maritime cooperation consistent with the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, or UNCLOS. Those understandings offer a foundation, not a finished architecture.
















