A “placebo” safety tool
According to documents released in the lawsuit led by New York Attorney General Letitia James, TikTok placed thousands of users trying to enable safety features into “ghost” or placebo tests. While users believed the tool was working, their feeds stayed the same, unlike those given the fully functional version.
The suit argues that while TikTok publicly says safety is paramount and the app is suitable for young people, it deliberately blocked certain groups from accessing safety tools, even when they explicitly sought to avoid harmful content. New York also alleges that TikTok misled the public by saying “Algo Refresh” would reset the recommendation algorithm, when the effect was only temporary.
Internal warnings ignored
According to internal records cited in the suit, a product manager in TikTok's Digital Well Being team objected to placebo tests on the Algo Refresh tool, warning that the practice was problematic and likely to mislead users.
Despite the warning, TikTok allegedly ran the experiments repeatedly on thousands of users throughout 2023, comparing those denied the working feature with those who received it to analyse engagement time on the platform and the effect on advertising revenue.
















