MAIN CONTENT
Judicial Penalties and the Separation of Technical Fault from Malice
The unanimous ruling issued by Brazil’s highest electoral authority in Brasilia marks a defining benchmark for digital constitutionalism. Justice Marco Aurelio Bellizze underscored that the 7.5 million reais penalty was formulated to reprimand Meta’s conduct in its entirety—specifically addressing recurrent patterns of unfulfilled mandates, partial document submissions, and late replies to binding court inquiries during an intensely competitive election window.
The financial punitive structure incorporated daily sanctions of 500,000 reais assessed between October 17 and 19, escalating to 1 million reais per day throughout the critical final phase from October 20 to 25. Nevertheless, the court drew an unambiguous legal boundary: while technical shortcomings acknowledged by Facebook justified strict punitive measures, asserting deliberate electoral manipulation requires rigorous, substantiated evidence established through formal adversarial proceedings.
"The records contain technical failures acknowledged by Facebook itself, but there are no elements allowing us to conclude, on a preliminary basis, that there was deliberate action to unbalance the election." — Marco Aurelio Bellizze
















