MAIN CONTENT
Two courts and two routes to reversal
At the November 16 hearing, Trump attorney Robert Giuffra Jr. asked federal appellate judges to intervene quickly and move the prosecution out of New York’s state-court system. His team argues that a federal forum would allow a fuller attempt to vacate the verdict under the Supreme Court’s rules on presidential immunity. The defense also wants to prevent the state appeal from moving forward while the federal question is examined.
The judges probed whether such an unusual procedure was actually authorized. Judge John M. Walker Jr. asked what would happen to briefs and arguments already heard in state court. Chief Judge Raymond J. Lohier Jr. questioned the legal mechanism that would permit a completed state criminal trial to be moved after conviction. The panel did not immediately decide the issue after more than an hour of questioning.
Meanwhile, New York’s intermediate appellate court heard the conventional challenge on November 5. Trump’s lawyers disputed the admission of evidence involving White House communications and argued that the prosecutors’ legal theory was flawed. Manhattan prosecutors maintained that the guilty verdict should stand. The two cases are related, but a hearing about transfer does not itself overturn a conviction.

















