MAIN ARTICLE
What the grand jury was told
The defense challenges the information presented at an early, largely closed stage of the criminal process. Its filings, reported by South Carolina Public Radio, say David Owen of the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division told grand jurors that blood spatter had been discovered on the T-shirt Alex Murdaugh wore on the night Maggie and Paul were killed. The lawyers contrast that assertion with an earlier state laboratory finding that detected no human blood on the garment. No such blood-spatter finding was offered as evidence in the 2023 trial.
The second disputed account concerns shotgun ammunition. Defense attorneys contend Owen described guns on the Murdaugh property as loaded with the same combination of shells used in Paul’s killing, although the physical record did not support such a sweeping claim. That difference matters because a grand jury decides whether prosecutors have established the grounds to issue formal charges; it does not decide guilt, and its proceedings are different from the later adversarial trial.
Disagreement over testimony does not, by itself, establish deliberate deception or require dismissal. The legal question is whether any inaccurate statements crossed a threshold that undermines the indictments. The defense wants judicial scrutiny of the reliability of information placed before grand jurors. Prosecutors maintain that the disputed assertions, even if imperfect, must be weighed against the entirety of the evidence rather than treated as the entire case.
















