MAIN ARTICLE
The dispute reaches beyond borders
Ivanov challenges an argument advanced by Indigenous rights advocates Pavel Sulyandziga and Dmitry Berezhkov. While acknowledging Russia’s colonial history and Indigenous rights, they have questioned whether newly independent ethnic republics might slide into authoritarian rule. The disagreement is less about whether self-determination exists as a principle than about whether credible safeguards can be created when political authority changes hands.
For Ivanov, predicting a future dictatorship risks becoming a justification for permanently denying a community the chance to choose its political status. He argues that hypothetical failure should not settle today’s debate. His position is that of an advocate for sovereignty, however, not a verified expression of the preferences of all Sakha residents, whose political outlooks cannot be reduced to one voice.
There is also a serious counterargument: legal independence alone does not create competitive elections, independent courts or a free press. A new government might reproduce centralized rule, marginalize minorities or concentrate resource revenues. The more productive question therefore joins the right to choose with the obligations that follow: how should choices be made, and what protections should survive every possible constitutional outcome?














