MAIN STORY
Controversial advice from the judiciary's highest seat
The October 1 hearing in Jerusalem took place before an expanded panel of nine justices, reviewing appeals against decisions of the Central Elections Committee. According to The Times of Israel, Chief Justice Isaac Amit told Abu Shehadeh directly that a majority of justices favoured disqualification and recommended that he withdraw, giving him until Friday.
According to The Jerusalem Post, after Abu Shehadeh withdrew, the court closed the proceeding without ruling on whether the evidence against him met the legal threshold for disqualification. That is precisely what has led many to ask why the court chose to “advise” rather than rule.
“There is a majority for your disqualification. We recommend that Abu Shehadeh withdraw from the race.” — Isaac Amit
The October 8, 2023 article and the limits of free speech
The case against Abu Shehadeh centres on a single Arabic-language article. The key elements include:














