A 2-1 ruling from the 9th Circuit
The San Francisco-based appeals court found that Dr Stacey Seyb, who challenged Idaho’s ban, is unlikely to succeed on the argument that the Constitution protects a right to a health-saving abortion. The decision lifted an August ruling by a federal judge that had ordered Idaho to allow abortions when a doctor deemed them necessary to protect the mother’s health, pending the state’s appeal.
The judge had later narrowed his ruling to bar enforcement only against the plaintiff.
The original ruling had blocked enforcement of two Idaho laws to the extent that they prohibited doctors from providing abortion care to patients with serious medical conditions, including high-risk mental health conditions.
















