An unprecedented legal argument
Last week, Louisiana, Alabama and Arkansas filed two lawsuits. The first, against New York, California and Massachusetts, was filed directly with the US Supreme Court, which can hear disputes between states that have not gone through lower courts but routinely turns such cases away. The second, naming nearly 30 medical practitioners and groups, was filed in federal court in Louisiana.
Experts say the suits are an unprecedented attempt to use public nuisance law to curb access to abortion pills, and the first direct challenge by states that ban abortion to other states' shield laws. The offices of the attorneys general of the three plaintiff states did not respond to requests for comment.
Two sides, two positions
In their court filings, the plaintiff states argue that both the shield laws and the conduct of out-of-state providers are classic examples of public nuisance, because they aim to thwart abortion bans the states adopted to protect public safety. They draw a comparison with a hypothetical state encouraging its residents to send dangerous items into other states.
















