A White House access dispute enters a new legal phase
At a hearing in Washington on October 8, counsel for the three organizations urged the court to issue a preliminary injunction preventing enforcement of the access ban during litigation. Such relief would allow their journalists to keep working on White House grounds while the lawsuit proceeds. It would not, by itself, settle the final merits of their constitutional claims.
The confrontation began in September after President Donald Trump accused CNN, MS NOW and Politico of disseminating inaccurate coverage of him. The organizations argue that the government cannot turn press credentials into rewards for favorable reporting or penalties for criticism. Under their theory, independent journalism becomes harder when any story that displeases a president can threaten a reporter’s physical access to government.
Attorney Theodore Boutrous pointed to the president’s own public comments as evidence that the policy was meant to influence what newsrooms publish. The danger, he argued, does not stop with the three organizations named in the order: reporters elsewhere could hesitate to publish legitimate but unflattering information if they believe their access might be revoked next.
Here we have the unusual situation where the president himself has said he wants to chill speech.















