A historic ruling from the highest court
The High Court of Australia dismissed MACH Energy's appeal with costs, closing a years-long legal journey over the Mount Pleasant open-cut coal mine near the town of Muswellbrook. The mine is due to end operations in December 2026. MACH Energy's expansion plan aimed to raise output to about 21 million tonnes a year and keep mining until 2048.
It was the first time Australia's top court had ruled on a climate change case. According to advocates, the decision will directly shape how New South Wales approves fossil fuel projects in the future.
The 98 percent that was ignored
At the heart of the case lies the concept of scope 3 emissions, the greenhouse gases released when a product is used, in this case when the coal is burned in importing countries. The key figures:
- Scope 3 emissions accounted for 98 percent of the Mount Pleasant project's total greenhouse gas emissions.
- Australian rules cover only direct emissions (scope 1 and 2) from facilities emitting more than 100,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent, requiring a 4.9 percent annual cut or the use of carbon offsets.
- Emissions generated overseas through the use of exported fossil fuels fall outside these rules.















