What the review found
The review was launched to assess KPMG’s suitability for government work after a whistleblower alleged that staff had misused confidential information to bid for new audit contracts. It concluded that the firm’s handling of the complaint fell well short of what was required.
“KPMG mishandled the whistleblower matter. Its response was misguided, fragmented, prolonged and, at critical points, lacked clear ownership.” — Review report
Although the whistleblower raised concerns about unethical conduct driven by commercial pressure and feared retaliation, the report said KPMG primarily treated the case as an employment issue and focused on legal implications and organisational risks, paying too little attention to whether the allegations might be accurate. KPMG initially said investigations had not substantiated the claims, before later inquiries uncovered serious ethical failings, damaging the whistleblower’s confidence as well as client and public trust.
No permanent ban, but no quick return
The Department of Finance said KPMG had agreed not to bid for new federal work until February 28 while it pursues governance reforms. The review recommended that the government not allow the firm to bid again until it has independently verified that reforms are being implemented and are changing behaviour in practice.














