The first legal challenge
The law, which bars large social media platforms from letting under-16s hold accounts, took effect in late 2025. Reddit and a libertarian advocacy group have filed suit in the High Court, the first legal challenge to the law. The Australian government and Communications Minister Anika Wells, a named defendant, say they will defend it.
Reddit's arguments
Perry Herzfeld, for Reddit, set out a series of arguments before the seven-judge panel:
- The law violates an implied freedom of political expression in Australia's constitution by stopping young people from creating or responding to content on the most important means of communication in the modern world.
- Reddit argues the law should not apply to it because it lacks some features central to social media, such as reliance on friend networks.
- Reddit agrees with the harm-minimisation aim but says the law fails to achieve it because it calls for no specific measures and ignores other online services where cyberbullying occurs, such as gaming sites.
*"That is a very profound restriction on political debate in Australia." — Perry Herzfeld*















