A new target: the courts’ power to set aside rules
The Supreme Court’s 2025 ruling clamped down on “universal” injunctions that can block the government from enforcing a policy against anyone, but it left untouched a separate tool: the courts’ claimed power under the APA to “hold unlawful and set aside” agency regulations, invalidating them on a universal basis.
According to the Trump administration, courts should not be able to shut down a regulation entirely, but should limit relief to the plaintiffs in a given case. Aditya Bamzai, an administrative law expert at the University of Virginia, said a win for Trump could let the government continue to enforce rules broadly, potentially for years as litigation plays out, even after judges have deemed them unlawful.
Whether you like or dislike that flexibility can perhaps depend on whether you like or dislike a particular administration’s policies.
From surprise medical bills to a battle over power
The case arises from rules implementing a statute Trump signed in his first term to limit unexpected medical bills from hospitals and providers outside a patient’s insurance network. A Texas association of medical doctors, air-ambulance providers and other plaintiffs argued that the regulation violated the APA and artificially deflated their reimbursement rates.
















