Anderson v. Intel
Anderson v. Intel raises a key question: when can an employee sue an employer for putting risky or unwise investments into a retirement plan? The plaintiff argues that Intel breached its fiduciary duty by including private equity and hedge funds in its defined-contribution retirement plan.
According to the plaintiff, these investments performed worse than standard equity funds would have. Last year, a federal appeals court dismissed the lawsuit. The Supreme Court debate hinged on whether a plaintiff must show underperformance against an appropriate benchmark for a suit to survive a motion to dismiss.
Justices Voice Scepticism
Several members of the court appeared to endorse the appeals court’s ruling dismissing the suit. Justices Samuel Alito, Ketanji Brown Jackson and Elena Kagan expressed puzzlement at aspects of the plaintiff’s argument, while some justices rejected the idea that underperformance alone gives 401(k) plan participants grounds to sue.
Whether a particular strategy is reasonable or not cannot be judged based on how that strategy performed in one particular instance.
















