MAIN CONTENT
A A$166,000 report and numbers that don’t add up
Deloitte examined three merger options among the universities, each with low, mid and high cost scenarios, setting out its calculations in the appendix. Yet basic sums fail to add up:
- High-cost scenario for a Curtin–UWA merger: “total costs to day 1” of A$514 million and five-year post-day-1 costs of A$145 million, totalling A$659 million – but the report says A$399 million, a A$260 million discrepancy.
- Low-cost scenario for a three-way merger: A$396 million and A$116 million, totalling A$512 million – but the report says A$823 million, a A$311 million discrepancy.
That is not all. The report repeatedly refers to Curtin as the “Curtin University of Technology,” a name it has not used since 2010 and which was changed by an act of state parliament in 2017. Guardian Australia also found that a reference to a World Health Organization report carries a ChatGPT metadata tag in its URL, indicating the link was sourced directly from the chatbot.
“AI slop” and the government’s response
Earlier this month, media revealed the report contained hallucinated AI references, prompting the state opposition to label it “AI slop.” Deloitte acknowledges in the report that it used generative AI to support the collation of research, synthesis of information and editorial proofing, and initially dismissed the errors as “minor.”














