An October 7 without a rally
On the previous two anniversaries, Tal Tsafrir, an Israeli tech worker in New York, spent all of October 7 campaigning for the release of the hostages held in Gaza. This year, he has no rally to organise. The remains of the last hostage were recovered in January, following exchanges between Israel and Hamas.
That emptiness does not mean peace. As Haaretz found through the stories of nine Israelis and Israeli-Americans, the past three years have deeply unsettled their sense of homeland, identity and place in a rapidly changing society.
Diverging paths
The tragedy of October 7 and the long war that followed did not push everyone in the same direction. Instead, they produced shifts in opposite directions:
- Some former liberals have moved to the right, putting security above all else.
- Some observant Jews have organised against the war, drawing on their own religious values.
- Some Israelis living abroad, like Tal Tsafrir, remain attached to home while agonising over its future.
These choices show that the question of what it means to be Israeli is being answered by each person in their own way, sometimes in contradictory and painful ways.















