An unanswered question in Berlin
At a dialogue workshop in Berlin where Israelis and Palestinians sat in the same room, a young Palestinian Christian woman from East Jerusalem asked Hamza Howidy a question that still haunts him. She condemned the actions of Hamas, but also saw clearly that diplomacy had never helped Palestinians. Armed resistance, negotiations, peaceful protest – all had been tried, she said, and all had failed. So what should Palestinians do to win self-determination and live free of occupation?
*“We want to live in dignity. We do not want to wait for the mercy of the international community.” — A Palestinian woman from East Jerusalem*
Howidy, the only person in the room from Gaza, recalls that his first answer was: “Nothing. We can do nothing.” It was one of the most depressing answers he had ever given. The woman turned away, and he thought he heard her mutter: “So it's armed resistance after all.” That moment became the starting point of the essay he wrote for the October 7 anniversary.
Three years after October 7: peace still out of reach
Asked to offer readers “a spark of hope,” Howidy called friends in Gaza and searched the news and social media, but found only insecurity and fear. He recalled the images of Hamas atrocities three years ago, when Israeli children and elderly people were abducted and dragged into tunnels. He also came across a Christian mother and her daughter caring for displaced families, and a university lecturer killed with her mother in an Israeli air strike on an apartment building.














