MAIN CONTENT
A murder case that lasted a quarter-century
Rob Andrew, a 39-year-old advertising executive and father, was shot in November 2001 in the garage of his former family home in Oklahoma City while collecting his children before Thanksgiving. Pavatt, who knew the family through church, was romantically involved with Rob's estranged wife, Brenda Andrew. The prosecution portrayed the killing as a planned effort rather than a sudden confrontation. It cited an earlier incident in which brake lines on Rob Andrew's vehicle had been cut, and prosecutors also identified an $800,000 life insurance policy as a possible motive.
After the death, Pavatt and Brenda Andrew took her children to Mexico and were detained after returning to the United States several months later. Separate juries convicted the two defendants; Brenda Andrew remains under a death sentence. Pavatt was convicted of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder. At his final clemency hearing he insisted he had not personally shot anyone, while acknowledging he understood why the jury believed both defendants were involved. The prosecution maintained that responsibility for a planned killing did not depend solely on who fired the weapon.
















