The final ruling in Melbourne
Justices Stephen McLeish, Lesley Taylor and Peter Kidd of Victoria’s Court of Appeal handed down two decisions at once: one on Patterson’s appeal against her convictions and one on the prosecution’s bid for a tougher sentence. Patterson was not in the courtroom, appearing only as a small figure on a large screen via video link from the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre, where she is serving her sentence.
Justice McLeish said the court had granted leave to appeal on just two of the seven grounds raised by the defence, but after consideration both were rejected. The remaining five, including a claim that the lead prosecutor had questioned her unfairly, were dismissed outright.
Patterson’s conduct was characterised by an elaborately staged series of deceptions.
Justice McLeish recounted the key details: the lie that she had cancer to bring her guests to the house, the planning of the lunch, the destruction of evidence and what he called the cruel breach of trust toward her own relatives.















