MAIN CONTENT
A shared figure, two competing political stories
Sun Yat-sen remains an unusually powerful symbol across the Taiwan Strait. His revolutionary movement helped bring down the Qing dynasty in 1911, clearing the way for the Republic of China. At the Great Hall of the People, Xi portrayed Sun’s commitment to national unity as an inheritance that contemporary China must complete. In Beijing’s telling, the question of Taiwan is unfinished business from a turbulent century; Xi called its resolution a historical mission for the Communist Party.
Taipei sees a different inheritance. The Republic of China government relocated to Taiwan after losing the Chinese civil war in 1949, while the People’s Republic of China was founded on the mainland. Taiwan subsequently developed its own democratic institutions. Sun is still honoured officially in Taiwan, but the island’s authorities argue that a shared historical figure does not settle who may govern its people. The dispute is not simply about a name on a monument; it concerns political consent, sovereignty and the meaning of self-government.
Peaceful language and the unresolved question of force
Xi emphasised dialogue, peaceful unification and Beijing’s “one-China principle,” under which it considers both sides of the strait part of one country. He did not mention force in this speech.
Yet Beijing has never ruled out its use, and Taiwan regularly reports Chinese military operations nearby. On November 12, Taiwan’s defence ministry said it had detected 29 Chinese aircraft, including fighter jets and drones, in a coordinated patrol with naval vessels.
The difference between a peaceful formulation and a reassuring security environment is therefore crucial. For Beijing, military pressure may be presented as deterrence against formal independence. In Taiwan, the same activities are widely viewed as coercion. The Mainland Affairs Council dismissed the offered “one country, two systems” approach, and spokesperson Liang Wen-chieh said the unification language differed little from previous statements. The apparent continuity matters: the speech was emphatic, but did not disclose a new negotiating framework.
Why the anniversary carries political weight
The choice of Sun’s 160th birthday offered Xi a moment to connect the party’s objectives with a revolutionary figure respected on both sides. Such historical framing can strengthen a message domestically while seeking a wider cultural audience. But a common reference point cannot erase the different political trajectories that followed 1949. Taiwan’s government had already urged residents to avoid Beijing’s commemorative activities, disputing China’s interpretation of Sun’s legacy.
These disagreements extend to memories of the Second World War. Taipei has objected to mainland accounts that, in its view, understate the Republic of China’s role in fighting Japan before the People’s Republic existed. Historical commemoration thus becomes a contest over legitimacy. Each side appeals to a past it regards as meaningful, while present-day residents confront concrete choices about security, rights and political representation.
A delicate diplomatic calendar
The speech also arrived shortly before an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Shenzhen, where Xi was expected to meet U.S. President Donald Trump, and ahead of local elections in Taiwan. Washington’s relationship with Beijing, its security ties with Taipei and the economic importance of the strait make seemingly ceremonial remarks consequential well beyond China and Taiwan. The region’s trade routes and technology supply chains heighten the stakes of any escalation.
Taiwan President Lai Ching-te argues that only the island’s people may determine its future; Beijing regards him as a separatist and refuses talks with his administration. Neither position was altered by the anniversary ceremony. The most revealing feature of the day may have been the distance between the language of shared heritage and the lack of a mutually accepted political process. A sustainable easing of tensions would require not only diplomacy, but credible assurances and space for those most affected to be heard.
















