MAIN CONTENT
“Sugar-free” and “no added sugar” are not the same claim
The lawsuit turns on two phrases that sound similar to consumers but are treated differently under U.S. food-labeling rules. FDA guidance says a “sugar-free” claim is generally reserved for foods containing less than 0.5 grams of sugars per applicable serving. “No added sugar,” by contrast, can describe a product to which no sugar was added during processing even though naturally occurring sugars, including lactose from milk, remain.
The plaintiffs argue that an ordinary consumer seeing “sugar-free” would expect sugar content to be negligible. A beverage containing many grams of naturally occurring sugar may therefore create a significant gap between the front-facing claim and the nutritional reality.
Eight protein beverages are named in the complaint
The case concerns hot and iced versions of vanilla- and caramel-flavored Protein Lattes and Protein Matcha drinks. Starbucks launched its expanded protein lineup in September 2025 as part of its “Back to Starbucks” menu strategy, positioning the products around higher protein and reduced added sugar.














