MAIN ARTICLE
Beyond replacement fears: Who holds decision-making power?
Predictions that robots and software will eliminate entire professions often dominate public debate. Yet the research picture is more measured than such sweeping claims. In a 2025 assessment, the International Labour Organization (ILO) and Poland’s research institute NASK estimated that one in four jobs worldwide had some potential exposure to generative AI. Crucially, exposure is not the same as layoffs: many roles may instead see changes in workflow, task allocation and skill requirements.
Bhabani Shankar Nayak, whose commentary appeared in Countercurrents on October 1 and was republished by MR Online on October 4, 2026, makes a normative argument: those whose labor produces data, knowledge and value should be able to shape technology built on collective human effort. It is a proposal about power and the distribution of benefits, not evidence that every collective-ownership structure has been proven successful.
For employees, this becomes tangible very quickly. Can an opaque system secretly score performance? How can someone challenge a mistaken assessment? Will employers use time saved to raise pay, reduce hours or offer training? Transparency about these decisions matters as much as the speed of an AI model.
















