A unanimous ruling, uneasy reasoning
Chief Justice Suhartoyo announced late on Tuesday in Jakarta that all nine judges had dismissed the petition. The petitioners, represented by lawyer Bambang Widjojanto and former deputy law and human rights minister Denny Indrayana, argued that Gibran's foreign secondary credentials failed to meet legal requirements and had been improperly accepted by the General Election Commission (KPU).
Under Indonesia's Election Law, presidential and vice-presidential candidates must have completed senior high school or hold an equivalent qualification. Gibran studied at Orchid Park Secondary School in Singapore and UTS Insearch in Sydney, Australia, before earning a bachelor's degree through the Management Development Institute of Singapore. Yet, according to the ruling, no high school graduation certificate was presented at any point during the case.
The decisive argument: the moment has passed
Judge Adies Kadir explained that the case could no longer be treated as a dispute over election results, because Gibran had been sworn in as vice president alongside President Prabowo Subianto in October 2024. In other words, the court drew a clear line between weighing evidence and having the power to act upon it.














