A predawn raid at the wrong address
On October 18, 2017, an FBI tactical team set out to execute warrants at a suspected gang location in suburban Atlanta. Instead, the agents arrived at the home occupied by Curtrina “Trina” Martin, Hilliard Toi Cliatt and Martin’s seven-year-old son. They forced the front door, used a flash-bang device and moved toward the bedroom. The residents had no reason to expect a police operation at their address.
As described in the Supreme Court record, Cliatt was restrained and Martin found herself confronting armed officers while her child cried out from another room. Once agents established that they had entered the wrong house, they apologized and moved on to the intended target. For the family, however, the incident did not end with the officers’ departure. They reported emotional harm and pursued damages.
Two different rulings on responsibility
On October 7, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit found that an exception to federal law protected the government from the family’s claims.















