MAIN CONTENT
The Supreme Court declines to reopen the case
On October 5, 2026, the Supreme Court declined to review Roy Moore’s petition against Senate Majority PAC, ending his principal avenue for restoring the verdict. As is common with denials of certiorari, the Court gave no detailed explanation, leaving the Eleventh Circuit’s judgment in place.
The Court had already rejected Moore’s emergency request in June to pause the appellate ruling while he prepared his petition. Monday’s denial therefore completed a reversal of fortunes for a plaintiff who had once secured a substantial jury award at trial.
From an $8.2 million jury award to reversal on appeal
In 2022, a federal jury found that Moore had been defamed and awarded him $8.2 million. The case focused on a television advertisement aired during Alabama’s 2017 special Senate race and financed by Senate Majority PAC through the group Highway 31.
Moore’s lawyers argued that the advertisement stitched together statements and partial quotations from different news stories to create an accusation no reporter had actually made. They said the overall presentation falsely suggested Moore had been accused of seeking sex with underage girls at a shopping mall.

















