MAIN ARTICLE
A firmer sentence, but one exhibit stays hidden
Victoria’s Court of Appeal, comprising Justices Stephen McLeish, Lesley Taylor and Peter Kidd, dismissed Erin Patterson’s challenge to her murder and attempted-murder convictions. The judges also upheld a prosecution appeal against sentence, removing the 33-year non-parole period imposed in September 2025. She now faces life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. The ruling changed the severity of punishment, not the jury’s findings about the crimes.
One excluded item nevertheless remains subject to a suppression order. ABC Australia reported that the published appellate reasons are partially redacted to protect information that trial judge Christopher Beale had ruled inadmissible in 2025. The court’s refusal to reveal it should not be taken as evidence of what the hidden material proves. Neither readers nor reporters can responsibly infer its substance merely from the fact of suppression.
The risk of publicity before any new jury hears the case
The legal rationale is forward-looking. Patterson may still seek special leave to appeal to Australia’s High Court. Although success is uncertain, a successful challenge could conceivably require a fresh trial.















